Confused dater

Ok, so here I was all excited just a few short days ago after my RetroMatch date, but now comes the confusing part. I recently met someone off of Jdate.com and he sounds even better than the RetroMatch.com guy. I'm really confused since I have a policy of only dating one at a time. Truth be told, the RetroMatch guy is 4 years younger than me and I think that our experiences are some what different. I asked him why he dates older women and his response to me was that they tend to understand him better due to their years of maturity. What's there to understand? I mean listen, I'm not trying to knock the guy or anything - he happens to be really fabulous and has even called me a couple of times since we went out. I decided to send him an email telling him that I'm a little unsure as to where we go from here. I think he's great and all, but his lack of experience in the dating world and his being a little naive is a bit odd to me and something I'm not used to. I'll wait and see what he has to say, but till then I'm going to correspond with Jdate.com guy and see what becomes of him.....